Nashville's Best Pie [Updated 2024]

Introduction: As an expert with years of experience, I am thrilled to present to you the ultimate guide to the best pie in Nashville! Having reviewed a total of 12 mouthwatering pies in this vibrant city, I can confidently declare that Nashville is a hidden gem for pie lovers. From classic flavors to innovative creations, Nashville's pie scene has something for everyone. So, whether you're a local or a visitor, join me on this delectable journey as we explore the finest pie establishments in Nashville. Prepare your taste buds for an unforgettable experience as we uncover the best pie this city has to offer. Let's dive in!

Five Daughters Bakery | East Nashville

Highlights
100 layer donuts
Fresh and fluffy
Great customer service
King Kong is a must-try
Clean and friendly

From the moment I walked into Five Daughters Bakery | East Nashville, I knew I was in for a treat. The air was filled with the sweet aroma of freshly baked pastries, and the display case was a heavenly sight. While I initially came in search of the best pie in Nashville, I couldn't resist trying their famous 100 layer donuts.

Let me tell you, these donuts are no ordinary treat. They are extraordinary. Each layer was fluffy, light, and bursting with flavor. I couldn't help but marvel at the artistry and skill that went into creating these delicate delights. It was like biting into a cloud that had been infused with all the sweet dreams a pie lover could imagine.

But don't be fooled, Five Daughters Bakery | East Nashville is not just about donuts. Their pies, like the King Kong pie, are legendary. The King Kong pie is a harmonious blend of rich chocolate, creamy peanut butter, and a touch of banana. It was an absolute symphony of flavors that danced on my taste buds.

Aside from the incredible desserts, another aspect that stood out was the great customer service. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about their products. They were more than happy to explain the different pie options and help me make my decision.

Lastly, I appreciate that the bakery is clean and friendly. The atmosphere is inviting, and the space is well-maintained. This not only added to my overall enjoyment but also gave me confidence in the quality of their pies.

In conclusion, if you're looking for the best pie in Nashville, Five Daughters Bakery | East Nashville is a must-visit. Their 100 layer donuts and the King Kong pie are truly exceptional. With their fresh and fluffy creations, along with their great customer service, this bakery is a standout in the Nashville pie scene.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Nashville.

Baked on 8th

Highlights
Delicious cakes
Amazing designs
Great customer service
Converts non-cake people
Wide variety of treats

Upon entering the cozy bakery, I was immediately drawn to the delectable display of delicious cakes. The variety was astounding, and I couldn't help but marvel at the amazing designs adorning each one. It was evident that Baked on 8th takes great pride in creating visually stunning masterpieces.

As I approached the counter, I was warmly greeted by the staff, who exuded a genuine passion for their craft. The great customer service made me feel right at home, like I was visiting a dear friend's place.

Now, let's get to the star of the show - the pie. One bite into the perfectly flaky crust, and I knew I had found something truly special. The fillings were bursting with rich, natural flavors that converted even the most die-hard non-cake people into instant fans.

One of the things that impressed me the most about Baked on 8th was the wide variety they offered. From classic flavors like apple and pecan to innovative creations like bourbon caramel and lavender honey, there was a treat to suit every palate.

In conclusion, Baked on 8th in Nashville is a delightful gem that should not be missed by any pie enthusiast. Their dedication to crafting delicious treats with breathtaking designs, coupled with their exceptional customer service, sets them apart from the rest. So, whether you're a fellow pie aficionado or just looking for a slice of happiness, make sure to pay Baked on 8th a visit - you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Nashville.

D’Andrews Bakery & Cafe

Highlights
Perfect start
Fluffy buns
Reasonable
Friendly staff
Unique donut

First and foremost, let me say that my visit to D’Andrews Bakery & Cafe was a perfect start to my quest for the best pie in Nashville. As soon as I entered the cozy café, the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pastries filled the air, immediately igniting my excitement.

One of the highlights of D’Andrews was their selection of pies. I couldn't resist trying their famous fluffy buns which were an absolute delight. The pie crust was light and flaky, perfectly complementing the velvety filling bursting with flavors. With each bite, I savored the harmonious blend of sweetness and texture, creating a truly indulgent experience.

What pleasantly surprised me further was the reasonable pricing of their pies. Not only did I enjoy a delightful slice of pie, but I also left with my wallet happy. The affordability factor adds an extra layer of satisfaction to the already delightful experience.

On top of the delectable treats, the staff at D’Andrews Bakery & Cafe were incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. They patiently walked me through their selection, indulging my curiosity with warmth and enthusiasm. Their friendliness added a sense of welcome and comfort to the entire experience, making me feel like a valued customer.

To conclude, D’Andrews Bakery & Cafe in Nashville truly stands out as a unique donut. With their impeccable pies, reasonable pricing, and friendly staff, it's no wonder why this cozy café holds a special place in the hearts (and stomachs!) of the locals. It's definitely a must-visit spot for any pie enthusiast like me.

You might also want to check out the best steak in Nashville.

Five Daughters Bakery | 12th South

Five Daughters Bakery | 12th South in Nashville is a pastry paradise. Their pies are a delightful culinary adventure. From the flaky crust to the perfectly balanced fillings, each bite is a symphony of flavors. It's like winning a pie-lympic gold medal. A must-visit for pie lovers!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Nashville.

Sweet Creations

The place was a sweet paradise, mesmerizing my taste buds with their heavenly pie creations. The crust was flaky and the fillings were bursting with flavor. Each bite left me craving more. Sweet Creations definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best pie places in Nashville!

You might also want to check out the best food in Pigeon Forge.

Dozen Bakery

Dozen Bakery in Nashville is a pie lover's paradise. With its delicate crust and flavorful fillings, each bite feels like a sweet symphony dancing on your taste buds. The charm of this place lies in its commitment to freshness and quality. It's a must-visit for any pie enthusiast in Nashville.

You might also want to check out the best dessert in Nashville.

Papa C Pies Bakery

Papa C Pies Bakery in Nashville is a delightful pie haven. The heavenly aroma wafting through the air is a testament to the artistry behind these pies. With a wide variety of flavors to choose from, each bite is a taste bud's dream come true. Don't miss out on their signature pecan pie, it's truly a slice of perfection. Papa C Pies Bakery is a must-visit for any pie enthusiast in Nashville.

You might also want to check out the best new restaurants in Nashville.

Shugga Hi Bakery AND Cafe

Shugga Hi Bakery AND Cafe in Nashville is a sweet haven for pie lovers. Their pies are flaky and flavorful, bursting with fresh fillings that will send your taste buds on a wild ride. With a charming ambiance and friendly staff, it's a must-visit spot for any pie aficionado in Music City!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Nashville.

Mattheessen's - Ice Cream, Cookies, Fudge

Mattheessen's - Ice Cream, Cookies, Fudge in Nashville is a delightful little treasure for pie enthusiasts like me. The sheer variety of flavors and textures they offer is mind-boggling! From classic apple to indulgent chocolate silk, their pies are nothing short of decadent. Trust me, this place is a must-visit for your pie cravings!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Nashville.

Butter, Eggs, & Bakin

Butter, Eggs, & Bakin in Nashville is a slice of pie paradise. Their playful selection of flavors, from classic apple to velvety chocolate peanut butter, is a delightful surprise. The buttery crusts and perfectly balanced fillings make every bite a heavenly escape. Nashville, you're in for a treat!

You might also want to check out the best barbeque in Nashville.

Yeast Nashville

Yeast Nashville is a dream come true for pie enthusiasts like myself. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted by the heavenly scent of freshly baked pies. The selection is mind-blowing with flavors ranging from classic apple to innovative creations like bourbon pecan. The crust is flaky perfection, and the fillings are lusciously balanced. Don't miss their signature pie, the Nashville Hot Chicken Pot Pie. It's an unexpected combination of savory and sweet that will leave you wanting more. So, if you're in Nashville and craving an outstanding pie, Yeast Nashville is where it's at!

NY Pie (Nashville West)

Upon visiting NY Pie (Nashville West) in Nashville, I was treated to a taste explosion of the best pizza pie. The crispy crust, ooey-gooey cheese, and flavorful toppings made for a top-notch pie experience. It's no wonder this place is a local favorite.